In the dawning years of the 21st century, the draw and appeal of homeopathy continues to grow as patients turn more and more to these often untried and usually non-studied remedies for every ailment that afflicts humankind. It is appealing to patients because first, they feel they are "taking control" of their condition, secondly, acting in heroic defiance of "big medicine" and an indifferent medical world and thirdly they are searching for that :magic bullet" that will cure lymphedema without any effort on their part as patients..
I have heard so many lymphedema patients announce they are endeavoring on a homeopathic treatment path because medical science has let them down. When confronted with the truth that almost all of these treatment substances have not been clinically studied or the efficacy verified, they often react swiftly with anger and resentment.
Sad, no more then sad, it is tragic. As I have spent many endless hours researching homeopathy, I remain unable to locate one independent double blind clinical study that substantiates the claim that homeopathy helps lymphedema. What happens when someone turns to this form of treatment often is a delay of seeking out solid, proven therapy such as MLD, compression bandages, and exercises. Without proper treatment, their condition worsens and more there is more damage to the lymph system.
Generally, these patients also fail to let their convention doctors know what they are doing and/or taking into their bodies. Since many of them, like myself, have serious other conditions, they put themselves at risk for serious complications and/or putting their lives in danger for toxicity as the conventional medicines react against the homeopathic medicines.
Defenders of homeopathy proclaim "it has proven the test of time" and "has been around for centuries."
Yes, that is true. it has been around for centuries and all through those centuries, people have died from diseases that were fatal then, and nothing more then a nuisance thanks to scientific evidence based medicine. Only in the age of evidence based medicine have so many diseases been conquered and life expectancies so elongated as they are today.
I remain steadfastly unconvinced on the value of homeopathy for several reasons. First, there is a serious lack of double blind independent clinical studies. Second, the studies that are out there have been done by homeopathic companies/representatives/practitioners who have a vested interest in the success of their product. Third, the studies have weak control/methods and have continually drawn criticism from the scientific community for this. Infact, a recent meta-analysis of clinical trials on the effectiveness of homeopathy has shown that earlier clinical trials showed signs of major weakness in methodology and reporting, and that homeopathy trials were less randomized and reported less on dropouts than other types of trials.
Plain and simple, homeopathy is unsupported by modern scientific research. Homeopathy may also be inherently dangerous too, because homeopaths offer a false hope that may discourage or delay proper treatment. The situation has become so serious that many countries who previously allowed homeopathic medicines to be covered under their national health plans have withdrawn that coverage. In some countries, such as the UK, there is even a rising uproar to ban homeopathy.
Before you are tempted, please take into consideration the above information, do your research and demand the very best scientifically proven treatment for your lymphedema (after-all, aren't you worth it?)
April 22, 2008
Disclaimer: This is presented for information only. Inclusion does not constitute an endorsement of the therapies and/or treatment. Individuals should consult with their physicians as to its applicability in their personal situation. Aromatherapy is often used in conjunction with manual lymphatic drainage therapy, complex decongestive therapy and reflexology therapy in lymphedema. One should always discuss this treatment option in full with their physician before they undertake any homeopathic treatment. Information provided below, except for the Abstracts and Studies section are provided by homeopathic websites.
When doing your own research on homeopathic medicine, I recommend visiting this site as part of your research:
Your Skeptical Guide to Homeopathic History, Theories, and Current Practices
Operated by Stephen Barrett, M.D.
What is Homeopathy?
The term homeopathy comes from the Greek words homeo, meaning similar, and pathos, meaning suffering or disease. Homeopathy is an alternative medical system. Alternative medical systems are built upon complete systems of theory and practice, and often have evolved apart from and earlier than the conventional medical approach used in the United States. Homeopathy takes a different approach from conventional medicine in diagnosing, classifying, and treating medical problems.
- Homeopathy seeks to stimulate the body's defense mechanisms and processes so as to prevent or treat illness.
- Treatment involves giving very small doses of substances called remedies that, according to homeopathy, would produce the same or similar symptoms of illness in healthy people if they were given in larger doses.
- Treatment in homeopathy is individualized (tailored to each person). Homeopathic practitioners select remedies according to a total picture of the patient, including not only symptoms but lifestyle, emotional and mental states, and other factors.
a. Conventional medicine, as defined by NCCAM, is medicine as practiced by holders of M.D. (medical doctor) or D.O. (doctor of osteopathy) degrees and by their allied health professionals, such as physical therapists, psychologists, and registered nurses. Some conventional medical practitioners are also practitioners of complementary and alternative medicine. To find out more about these terms, see the NCCAM fact sheet
What is the history of the discovery and use of homeopathy?
In the late 1700s, Samuel Hahnemann, a physician, chemist, and linguist in Germany, proposed a new approach to treating illness. This was at a time when the most common medical treatments were harsh, such as bloodletting, purging, blistering, and the use of sulfur and mercury. At the time, there were few effective medications for treating patients, and knowledge about their effects was limited.
Hahnemann was interested in developing a less-threatening approach to medicine. The first major step reportedly was when he was translating an herbal text and read about a treatment (cinchona bark) used to cure malaria. He took some cinchona bark and observed that, as a healthy person, he developed symptoms that were very similar to malaria symptoms. This led Hahnemann to consider that a substance may create symptoms that it can also relieve. This concept is called the "similia principle" or "like cures like." The similia principle had a prior history in medicine, from Hippocrates in Ancient Greece--who noted, for example, that recurrent vomiting could be treated with an emetic (such as ipecacuanha) that would be expected to make it worse--to folk medicine. Another way to view "like cures like" is that symptoms are part of the body's attempt to heal itself--for example, a fever can develop as a result of an immune response to an infection, and a cough may help to eliminate mucus--and medication may be given to support this self-healing response.
Hahnemann tested single, pure substances on himself and, in more dilute forms, on healthy volunteers. He kept meticulous records of his experiments and participants' responses, and he combined these observations with information from clinical practice, the known uses of herbs and other medicinal substances, and toxicology, eventually treating the sick and developing homeopathic clinical practice.
Hahnemann added two additional elements to homeopathy:
- A concept that became "potentization," which holds that systematically diluting a substance, with vigorous shaking at each step of dilution, makes the remedy more, not less, effective by extracting the vital essence of the substance. If dilution continues to a point where the substance's molecules are gone, homeopathy holds that the "memory" of them--that is, the effects they exerted on the surrounding water molecules--may still be therapeutic.
- A concept that treatment should be selected based upon a total picture of an individual and his symptoms, not solely upon symptoms of a disease. Homeopaths evaluate not only a person's physical symptoms but her emotions, mental states, lifestyle, nutrition, and other aspects. In homeopathy, different people with the same symptoms may receive different homeopathic remedies.
Hans Burch Gram, a Boston-born doctor, studied homeopathy in Europe and introduced it into the United States in 1825. European immigrants trained in homeopathy also made the treatment increasingly available in America. In 1835, the first homeopathic medical college was established in Allentown, Pennsylvania. By the turn of the 20th century, 8 percent of all American medical practitioners were homeopaths, and there were 20 homeopathic medical colleges and more than 100 homeopathic hospitals in the United States.
In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, numerous medical advances were made, such as the recognition of the mechanisms of disease; Pasteur's germ theory; the development of antiseptic techniques; and the discovery of ether anesthesia. In addition, a report (the so-called "Flexner Report") was released that triggered major changes in American medical education. Homeopathy was among the disciplines negatively affected by these developments. Most homeopathic medical schools closed down, and by the 1930s others had converted to conventional medical schools.
In the 1960s, homeopathy's popularity began to revive in the United States. According to a 1999 survey of Americans and their health, over 6 million Americans had used homeopathy in the preceding 12 months. The World Health Organization noted in 1994 that homeopathy had been integrated into the national health care systems of numerous countries, including Germany, the United Kingdom, India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, and Mexico. Several schools of practice exist within homeopathy.
Persons using homeopathy do so to address a range of health concerns, from wellness and prevention to treatment of injuries, diseases, and conditions. Studies have found that many people who seek homeopathic care seek it for help with a chronic medical condition. Many users of homeopathy treat themselves with homeopathic products and do not consult a professional.